Once I was playing Yahtzee with my daughter. She was three. (It was a child’s version. She’s not some kind of Yahtzee savant.) After she rolled her three turns and didn’t get her desired result, she wanted another one. Thinking it was cute, I went ahead and let her go again. When she still didn’t get her desired result, she asked again and I, again, obliged. This went on a few more times until she rolled the “yahtzee” she’d been looking for. When the game was over and the points were counted, she had beaten me handily; in large part to the thirty-five or forty extra rolls she was allowed. She jumped up and down taunting “I WON! DADDY LOST! I WON! DADDY LOST!” (Yes, she was taunting.) That didn’t seem so cute. Sure, she had won, but only because I had allowed her to. It’s not the sour grapes driving that last sentence. Winning or losing against a three-year old is hardly worth getting excited about. I just wanted her and I to have a good time, which we did, even with the taunting.
A few days later, we played again. This time, when she asked for extra rolls, I said “No,” and that “It was against the rules.” This ignited a fury in her I had only seen while turning off “Yo Gabba Gabba” and telling her it’s bedtime. She dropped to the floor and bawled her eyes out, kicking the ground and screaming as loud as her little vocal chords would allow. When my wife entered the room and asked her what had happened, she sobbed “Daddy isn’t being fair.” I explained my stance and my wife stared me down like I was an over competitive psychotic who needed to win so badly that he’d crush his daughter’s fragile ego to do so. I explained that she needs to know how to play within the rules; that cheating is no way to win a game. It wasn’t competitive. It was a life lesson.
Understand, I knew my three-year old daughter was not intentionally cheating. She didn’t even realize the concept yet. But, she understood the philosophy of winning at all costs. The idea of a game is to win, and, to her and most children her age, this needs to be accomplished by any means necessary. What I had effectively done by allowing her extra rolls the first time we played, then allowing her to exuberantly celebrate her victory, was to reinforce that belief. Now, it was my responsibility to teach her that winning isn’t always the point of playing a game, especially if you play outside the rules to do so.